Philadelphia cheese

High Society” is not a bad movie – it’s really not. In a vacuum, it would be quite a fun musical. How can you go wrong with the musical talents of Bing Crosby and Frank Sinatra, fighting over the non-musical but always radiant Grace Kelly? And there’s even Louis Armstrong around as a bonus.

But the trouble is that “High Society” does not exist in a vacuum. It’s a musical remake of one of the all-time classic screwball comedies, “The Philadelphia Story.”

When “High Society” came out, long before DVD, Netflix or Turner Classic Movies, remakes didn’t have to look over their shoulder quite as much as they do today, when all of the previous versions are on tap. Nowadays, a remake has to compete with every single one of its previous versions.

When Bing is introduced in “High Society” as musician C.K. Dexter Haven, it just sounds wrong. Cary Grant is C.K. Dexter Haven, and he’s definitely not a musician. Grace Kelly is beautiful just being Grace Kelly, but only Katharine Hepburn is Tracy Lord. And Jimmy Stewart is Macaulay Connor, the gifted writer forced to slum at a gossip magazine. Sinatra, whose character in “High Society” is named “Mike,” just doesn’t seem right for the part.

“High Society” is not without its charms. But it will always be an imitation of the real thing.

3 thoughts on “Philadelphia cheese

  1. I both agree and agree to disagree. 🙂 I think both movies are great as well! But I think The Philadelphia Story is better for slightly different reasons. I really don’t have that much of a problem with the casting. My problem is that this movie just doesn’t have the same ebb and flow of its predecessor. High Society has an all-star cast, a fantastic story (as clearly seen in The Philadelphia Story), and an amazing soundtrack (it’s Cole Porter for crying out loud)! But somehow the great story and great soundtrack don’t seem to go together as well as I had hoped. Both still great movies! But The Philadelphia Story seems to have a better grip on the “story” (no pun intended).

  2. I can see what you’re saying. I’m not saying that Crosby or Kelly are necessarily miscast, just that, for me, Cary Grant and Katharine Hepburn are the definitive portrayals of those characters, making anyone else seem like an imitation. (I do think Sinatra is a little miscast, as I said in the post.)

  3. I can go along with that, but the duet that Crosby and Sinatra do later in the film kinda makes up for that miscast in my mind. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *